Evaluating Personal Injury Attorney Track Records

An attorney's track record is the best predictor of future success. Learn how to research, verify, and evaluate legal professionals based on their actual case results and experience.

Essential Truth

A strong track record should include specific case results, verified trial experience, and a pattern of maximum compensation recovery - not just years in practice or generic claims of success.

Key Elements of a Strong Track Record

Track Record Element	Importance	What to Look For	Red Flags
Case Results	Critical	Settlement amounts, verdicts, case types	Vague claims, unverifiable results
Trial Experience	Critical	Number of trials, jury verdicts, win rate	No trial experience, settlement mill
Years of Practice	Important	PI-specific experience, not just total years	New to personal injury law
Professional Recognition	Important	Awards, peer ratings, certifications	No professional recognition
Client Testimonials	Valuable	Specific results, satisfaction stories	Generic or fake reviews
Media Coverage	Valuable	News articles, significant cases	Negative publicity, sanctions

How to Research Attorney Track Records

1Start with Official Records

Begin your research with verified, official sources:

• State Bar Directory: Verify license, check disciplinary history
• Court Records: Search for recent trial results and case filings
• Professional Directories: Check Martindale-Hubbell, Avvo ratings
• Legal Awards: Verify Super Lawyers, Best Lawyers recognition

2Analyze Case Results

Look for specific, verifiable case outcomes:

• Settlement Amounts: Recent cases with specific dollar figures
• Verdict History: Jury awards from actual trials
• Case Complexity: Difficult cases successfully resolved
• Case Types: Experience relevant to your injury

3Verify Claims and Results

Don't take self-reported results at face value:

• News Articles: Media coverage of significant cases
• Court Records: Public filings showing actual results
• Client References: Direct testimonials from past clients
• Peer Recognition: Awards from legal organizations

4Assess Recent Performance

Focus on current, relevant experience:

• Recent Cases: Results from the last 2-3 years
• Current Practice: Active personal injury focus
• Trend Analysis: Consistent success over time
• Market Changes: Adaptation to legal developments

Verification Sources and Reliability

State Bar Association

High - Official record

What You Can Find:

License status, disciplinary actions, basic info

How to Access:

State bar website lawyer directory

Court Records

High - Public record

What You Can Find:

Trial results, case filings, judgments

How to Access:

Courthouse records, online databases

Legal Directories

Medium-High - Peer reviewed

What You Can Find:

Peer ratings, practice areas, experience

How to Access:

Martindale-Hubbell, Avvo, Best Lawyers

News Coverage

Medium - Journalistic standards

What You Can Find:

Notable cases, settlements, legal trends

How to Access:

Google news search, local media

Attorney Website

Low-Medium - Self-reported

What You Can Find:

Self-reported results, case examples

How to Access:

Law firm website, bio pages

Questions to Ask About Track Record

Case Results Questions

• Can you provide specific examples of cases like mine?
• What was your largest settlement or verdict last year?
• How many personal injury trials have you conducted?
• What percentage of your cases go to trial?
• Can you provide references from recent clients?
• What's your average case resolution time?

Experience Verification

• Where can I verify your case results?
• Have any of your cases been covered in the news?
• What professional recognition have you received?
• Are you board certified in personal injury?
• What continuing education do you pursue?
• How has your practice evolved over the years?

Red Flags in Track Record Claims

Warning Signs to Avoid

Suspicious Claims:

• "Millions recovered" without specifics
• Only old case results (5+ years ago)
• Unverifiable settlement amounts
• Claims of 100% success rate
• No trial experience mentioned

Research Red Flags:

• No verifiable public records
• Disciplinary actions or sanctions
• Primarily practices other areas of law
• Refuses to provide case references
• No professional recognition or awards

Evaluating Different Types of Results

Settlement Results

90% of personal injury cases settle out of court. Look for:

• Negotiated amounts vs. initial offers
• Speed of resolution
• Client satisfaction with process
• Pre-litigation vs. lawsuit settlements

Trial Verdicts

Trial results show litigation skill and dedication:

• Jury award amounts
• Complex liability cases won
• Appellate court victories
• Willingness to go to trial

Case Complexity

Difficult cases demonstrate true skill:

• Multi-defendant cases
• Disputed liability situations
• Complex medical issues
• Insurance bad faith claims

Using Track Record in Your Decision

Making the Final Assessment

A strong track record should demonstrate:

• Relevant Experience: Similar cases to yours with good outcomes
• Recent Success: Current results, not just historical achievements
• Verifiable Results: Claims you can independently confirm
• Trial Readiness: Willingness and ability to go to court
• Client Satisfaction: Happy clients who would recommend them
• Professional Recognition: Peer and industry acknowledgment

Remember: Context Matters

Track records should be evaluated in context. An attorney with a 90% success rate who only takes easy cases may not be better than one with an 80% rate who handles complex, challenging cases. Look for attorneys who combine strong results with willingness to fight for maximum compensation.

Research Before You Hire

A strong track record is your best guarantee of quality representation. Take time to verify claims and choose an attorney with proven results.

Success Rate Guide Review Research Guide