Injury Claim Support

Personal Injury Lawyer Consultation Questions

The right questions during your consultation will help you evaluate attorneys and make an informed decision. Use this comprehensive guide to prepare for productive meetings.

Consultation Strategy

Treat consultations like job interviews - you're hiring them to represent your interests. Ask detailed questions about experience, strategy, and fees to make the best choice for your case.

Essential Questions by Category

Experience & Qualifications

Critical Questions
How long have you been practicing personal injury law?
What percentage of your practice is personal injury?
How many cases like mine have you handled in the past year?
Are you board certified in personal injury or trial advocacy?
What is your track record with cases similar to mine?
Have you handled cases against this defendant/insurance company before?

Case Strategy & Approach

Critical Questions
What is your initial assessment of my case?
What do you think my case is worth?
What are the strengths and weaknesses of my case?
How will you investigate and build my case?
What experts might you need to consult?
How long do you expect my case to take?

Trial Experience & Willingness

Critical Questions
How many personal injury cases have you taken to trial?
When was your last jury trial?
What is your trial win rate?
Are you willing to take my case to trial if necessary?
How do you decide whether to settle or go to trial?
Have you tried cases in the court where mine would be filed?

Fee Structure & Costs

Critical Questions
Do you work on contingency, and what is your percentage?
Does your fee change if the case goes to trial?
Who pays for case expenses during litigation?
What happens to expenses if we lose the case?
Are there any upfront costs I need to pay?
Can you provide a written fee agreement?

Communication & Case Management

High Questions
Who will be the primary attorney on my case?
Will you personally handle my case or delegate to associates?
How often will you update me on my case progress?
What is the best way to contact you?
How quickly do you typically respond to client calls/emails?
How many other cases are you currently handling?

Resources & Support

High Questions
What resources will you invest in my case?
Do you have investigators on staff or do you hire them?
How do you handle medical records and expert testimony?
What support staff will work on my case?
Do you have the financial resources to fund litigation?
How do you handle complex medical or technical issues?

Preparing for Your Consultation

Documents to Bring

  • Police report or incident report
  • All medical records and bills
  • Insurance policies and correspondence
  • Photos of injuries, property damage, accident scene
  • Employment records and pay stubs
  • Any correspondence with insurance companies
  • Witness contact information
  • List of all medical providers

Information to Prepare

  • Detailed timeline of the accident
  • Complete medical treatment history
  • Work missed and income lost
  • Daily activities affected by injuries
  • Insurance coverage details
  • Prior injuries or medical conditions
  • Family impact and support needs
  • Financial hardships caused by accident

Follow-Up Questions Based on Responses

If They Say "I Handle All Types of Cases"

  • • What percentage of your time is spent on personal injury?
  • • How many personal injury cases did you close last year?
  • • When did you last take a personal injury case to trial?
  • • Do you have partners who specialize in personal injury?

If They Quote a High Case Value

  • • What specific factors make you think my case is worth that much?
  • • Can you show me similar cases you've handled with those results?
  • • What if the insurance company disputes liability or damages?
  • • How long would it take to reach that value?

If They Seem to Avoid Trial Discussion

  • • Do you prefer to settle cases or take them to trial?
  • • What would make you recommend going to trial?
  • • How do insurance companies view your willingness to try cases?
  • • Can you provide examples of recent trial results?

If Fee Structure Seems Unclear

  • • Can you break down exactly what I would pay in different scenarios?
  • • What expenses should I expect and when are they paid?
  • • Do you advance all costs or do I pay anything upfront?
  • • Is your fee agreement in writing and can I review it?

Warning Signs During Consultation

⚠️

Guarantees Specific Results

No ethical attorney can guarantee specific outcomes or settlement amounts.

⚠️

High-Pressure Tactics

Pressuring you to sign immediately without time to review is unprofessional.

⚠️

No Trial Experience

Attorneys who never try cases may be "settlement mills" that accept low offers.

⚠️

Vague About Experience

Cannot or will not provide specific information about similar cases handled.

⚠️

Poor Communication

Difficult to reach, doesn't return calls, or provides unclear explanations.

⚠️

Requests Upfront Payment

Personal injury cases should be handled on contingency with no upfront fees.

Making the Most of Your Consultation

During the Meeting

  • Take notes: Record answers to key questions
  • Ask for clarification: Don't pretend to understand
  • Assess communication: Are they clear and patient?
  • Evaluate the office: Professional, organized, busy?
  • Meet the team: Who else would work on your case?
  • Trust your instincts: Do you feel comfortable with them?

After the Meeting

  • Review your notes: Compare responses across attorneys
  • Check references: Contact past clients if provided
  • Verify credentials: Confirm bar status and experience
  • Compare approaches: Different strategies and timelines
  • Consider total package: Experience, fees, communication
  • Don't rush: Take time to make the right decision

Questions to Ask Yourself After Each Consultation

Self-Assessment Checklist

About the Attorney:

  • • Did they demonstrate relevant experience?
  • • Were they knowledgeable about my type of case?
  • • Did they explain things clearly?
  • • Did they seem genuinely interested in helping?
  • • Would I be comfortable working with them long-term?

About the Case:

  • • Did their case assessment seem realistic?
  • • Did they identify potential problems honestly?
  • • Was their strategy approach logical?
  • • Did they explain the timeline clearly?
  • • Were fees and costs transparent?

Special Considerations for Complex Cases

Medical Malpractice Cases

  • • How many medical malpractice cases have you handled?
  • • Do you work with specific medical experts regularly?
  • • Are you familiar with the medical standard of care issues in my case?
  • • How do you handle the medical review requirements?

Product Liability Cases

  • • Have you handled cases against this manufacturer before?
  • • Do you have experience with product defect analysis?
  • • How do you handle the technical aspects of product cases?
  • • Are you prepared for complex, multi-party litigation?

Wrongful Death Cases

  • • How many wrongful death cases have you handled?
  • • How do you calculate damages in wrongful death cases?
  • • Are you experienced with the emotional aspects of these cases?
  • • How do you handle multiple beneficiaries or family conflicts?

Remember: You're in Control

Free consultations are designed to help you evaluate attorneys, not for attorneys to pressure you into hiring them. Take your time, ask all your questions, and don't sign anything during the first meeting unless you're completely confident in your choice.

Make Informed Attorney Decisions

Use these questions to thoroughly evaluate personal injury attorneys and choose the best legal representation for your specific case and needs.