Personal Injury Case Evaluation Guide

Understanding how lawyers evaluate personal injury cases helps you choose the right attorney and set realistic expectations for your potential compensation.

Key Insight

Case evaluation is both art and science - lawyers analyze liability, damages, and insurance coverage while considering factors like jury appeal and litigation costs to determine true case value.

Critical Case Evaluation Factors

Factor	Importance	Description	Strong vs. Weak
Liability (Fault)	Critical	How clear is the other party's responsibility	✓ Clear defendant fault with evidence ✗ Disputed fault or shared responsibility
Injury Severity	Critical	Extent and permanence of injuries	✓ Significant, documented injuries ✗ Minor injuries with full recovery
Medical Documentation	Critical	Quality and completeness of medical records	✓ Thorough treatment records, specialist care ✗ Gap in treatment, minimal documentation
Economic Damages	High	Calculable financial losses	✓ High medical bills, lost wages ✗ Minimal financial impact
Insurance Coverage	High	Available insurance to pay damages	✓ High policy limits, multiple sources ✗ Minimum coverage, uninsured defendant
Pain and Suffering	Important	Non-economic impact of injuries	✓ Significant life impact, ongoing pain ✗ Temporary inconvenience only
Client Credibility	Important	How believable and likeable the client is	✓ Honest, sympathetic, consistent ✗ Criminal history, dishonesty, unlikeable

Typical Case Value Ranges

Minor Soft Tissue Injuries

$3,000 - $15,000

Key Factors:

Limited treatment, full recovery expected

Typical Timeline:

3-6 months

Moderate Injuries (Fractures)

$15,000 - $75,000

Key Factors:

Surgery required, some permanent impact

Typical Timeline:

6-12 months

Serious Injuries (Multiple)

$75,000 - $300,000

Key Factors:

Multiple surgeries, ongoing treatment

Typical Timeline:

12-24 months

Catastrophic Injuries

$300,000 - $2M+

Key Factors:

Permanent disability, lifelong care needs

Typical Timeline:

18-36 months

Wrongful Death

$500,000 - $5M+

Key Factors:

Age, income, family dependents

Typical Timeline:

24-48 months

The Case Evaluation Process

1Initial Case Review

The attorney's first assessment focuses on:

• Liability Analysis: Who was at fault and can it be proven?
• Injury Assessment: Severity and long-term impact
• Statute of Limitations: Time remaining to file lawsuit
• Insurance Investigation: Available coverage and limits
• Case Merit: Likelihood of successful outcome

2Medical Record Analysis

Detailed review of all medical documentation:

• Emergency Room Records: Initial treatment and diagnosis
• Treatment History: Ongoing care and specialist consultations
• Diagnostic Results: X-rays, MRIs, CT scans
• Prognosis Reports: Future treatment needs and recovery
• Work Restrictions: Impact on employment and activities

3Damage Calculation

Comprehensive assessment of all damages:

• Economic Damages: Medical bills, lost wages, future costs
• Non-Economic Damages: Pain, suffering, emotional distress
• Special Damages: Property damage, transportation costs
• Future Damages: Ongoing care, reduced earning capacity
• Life Impact: Activity limitations, relationship effects

4Settlement vs. Trial Analysis

Strategic evaluation of resolution options:

• Settlement Likelihood: Insurance company cooperation
• Trial Risk Assessment: Jury appeal and verdict potential
• Cost-Benefit Analysis: Litigation expenses vs. recovery
• Timeline Considerations: Client needs and case complexity
• Negotiation Strategy: Optimal approach for maximum recovery

What Makes a Strong Case

Strong Case Indicators

• Clear liability: Obvious fault with evidence
• Significant injuries: Objective medical findings
• Consistent treatment: Regular medical care without gaps
• High insurance limits: Adequate coverage available
• Good documentation: Photos, witnesses, police reports
• Credible client: Honest, likeable, consistent story
• Economic impact: Substantial financial losses
• Expert support: Medical professionals backing claims

Case Weaknesses

• Disputed liability: Unclear fault or shared responsibility
• Minor injuries: Soft tissue only, full recovery
• Treatment gaps: Delays or inconsistent medical care
• Low insurance: Minimum coverage, uninsured defendants
• Poor documentation: Missing evidence, no witnesses
• Client issues: Criminal history, inconsistent statements
• Pre-existing conditions: Difficult to separate injuries
• Statute problems: Late filing, missed deadlines

Questions Lawyers Ask During Evaluation

Liability Questions

• How did the accident happen?
• Were there any witnesses?
• Was a police report filed?
• Do you have photos of the scene?
• Were you partially at fault?
• Was alcohol or drugs involved?
• Are there traffic camera videos?

Damage Questions

• What injuries did you sustain?
• Did you go to the emergency room?
• Are you still receiving treatment?
• How much work have you missed?
• What's your annual income?
• Do you have health insurance?
• How has this affected your daily life?

Getting an Accurate Case Evaluation

Prepare for Your Consultation

Bring These Documents:

• Police reports or incident reports
• All medical records and bills
• Insurance policies and correspondence
• Employment records and pay stubs
• Photos of injuries and property damage
• Witness contact information

Be Ready to Discuss:

• Detailed accident circumstances
• Complete injury and treatment timeline
• Work impact and lost income
• Daily life changes and limitations
• Future medical needs and concerns
• Insurance coverage and communications

Understanding Evaluation Limitations

Why Initial Evaluations May Change

• Medical developments: Injuries may worsen or improve over time
• Additional evidence: New information may strengthen or weaken the case
• Insurance discoveries: Coverage amounts may be different than expected
• Legal precedents: Court decisions may affect similar cases
• Economic factors: Medical costs and lost wages continue to accrue
• Client factors: Compliance with treatment affects recovery

Get a Professional Case Evaluation

Understanding how lawyers evaluate cases helps you choose the right attorney and set realistic expectations. Most personal injury attorneys offer free case evaluations.

Get Free Evaluation Consultation Questions